Here’s why the market has gone whacko over Italy’s Paolo Savona, and why we should be prepared for a reversal in the Euro
It’s looking increasingly likely that all the market fuss over proposed finance minister Savona has come from a complete witch hunt from the Italian press, and is forcing a rethink by the two coalition party leaders.
I’ll try and put this as simply as possible but it’s one hell of a spider’s web to untangle;
- Salvini has been interviewed on TV this evening and one of the pressure questions was over a supposed “Plan B” proposed by Savona whereby Italy leaves the euro
- This Plan B is an idea that Savona collaborated on in 2015
- In it, was references on certain actions that Italy could take, such as; Printing 8 billion lira (or whatever new Italian money) in a few weeks in complete secrecy, announce that Italy is coming out of Euro (“D-Day”) on a Friday evening just after the market closing and on the following Monday morning launch the new lira, put through a devaluation of 15-25%, try to get a “partial” default of the public debt, to be agreed with creditors and send a warning about this move to the IMF and main central banks just before Monday morning before market opening. The full set of slides from 2015 can be found here (in Italian) You’ll see Savona’s name on the last slide
- Savona, in two press releases dated 27th & 28th of May 2018 stated (the 28th being a response to the Mattarella knock back) that in his role as finance minister, “That I would never question the euro, but I would have asked the European Union to give answers to the needs for change that come from within all member countries”
- The Italian press tonight is trying to link Salvini to the “Plan B” that was published, something he didn’t clearly refute
So, it seems that the market is jumping all over the fact that this “Plan B” is being pushed forward by the Italian press as the will of Savona if he becomes finance minister, even when he’s painted a completely different picture since then, and agreed with the coalition agreement that Italy will look to address needed changes as part of Italy’s membership and not look to leave. Now, there’s a big case to say a leopard doesn’t change his spots, and so the market worries might be well justified but the bigger play looks to be a push from the establishment not to have Savona as finance minister at all, and now both Di Maio and Salvini are back tracking somewhat on what Savona’s views might actually be deep down, and also the impeachment threat to the president.
Where does this leave us all?
There’s a strong possibility that if Di Maio and Salvini feel pressured enough, it could result in them pulling Savona’s name from the fin min job and replacing him with someone else. That would also mean that a new election is not necessary as the president may find the new fin min candidate acceptable and can move on with forming the government. Such a move would be very EUR positive on two fronts. 1. Because of removing the negative market risk of Savona, and 2. Wiping the need for Italy to go to the polls again. In such a circumstance the market could go very quickly from expecting new elections to Italy actually having a government in place. It also might explain why Cottarelli was sent away without a deal if Mattarella is giving the two leaders a chance to dump Savona and get back to trying to form a government.
This is something to watch out for over the hours and trading sessions ahead. It might all come to nothing but piecing together all the things happening today, and getting some additional background details on the subject means we potentially have a possibly very positive EUR outcome to watch for.
Remember though, this is politics and nothing is agreed or ruled out until everything is officially agreed and ruled out.
Once again, a huge thanks to our man on the spot, 5 Magics, who has been instrumental in helping us piece all this together.
- How much real FX liquidity is currently missing from the market? - April 1, 2020
- Are we at the end of the volatility? - March 31, 2020
- Governments and policies adapting to critical known unknown - March 30, 2020